Hugo homework continues. I and my reading buddies are posting about it real time on the
sync read post, but also posting here as I finish things I consider stand-alone books (novellas and longer) and complete categories:
11. Emily Tesh, The Incandescent – Hugo homework furnished me with a copy and a deadline, but I’ve been curious to read it for a while, because a number of my flisters had, and I’d even seen some of their Yuletide requests. I was also approaching it with a bit of trepidation, because so far everything I’ve read by Emily Tesh started out being great and then disappointed me in the ending to some degree. I think maybe my expectations are getting calibrated appropriately, because I was less disappointed by this ending than by aspects of
Some Desperate Glory, let alone the entire second novella of the Greenhollow duology, but I was also less excited about the beginning.
( More, with spoilers )I liked the individual components of the book – the magic school from a teacher’s perspective was great! I liked the students, I thought the central character and her arc were interesting even if I didn’t like her much. I do think it’s put together in a very weird way that doesn’t do it any favors as a novel, and Emily Tesh’s inability to write endings that I find satisfying strikes again – so I think I’m left more frustrated than won over by the whole…But I’m glad this book exists, and that I read it, for the teaching-of-magic aspects, and general teaching-as-vocation feels (which were well-timed for the weekend of attending my younger child’s probably-last graduation). I would not be mad if it wins a Hugo.
*
I found a chance to catch up on
Taskmaster Australia s5e06. I was actually going to wait until I came back from Europe and binge the rest of the season, but a Reddit post hinted at ep 6 having something extraordinary, so I decided to carve out the time.
( Spoilers! )*
Meme stolen from a couple of flisters:
( Some questions about books )